JSC to answer for alleged unconstitutional practices

South Africa
Lawyers groups are threatening to take the Judicial Services Commission to task on how it appoints judges. eNCA

Cape Town - The body tasked with appointing South Africa’s judges is divided on how to make the judiciary representative of South African society.

Last week, Judicial Services Commissioner Izak Smuts appointed to represent advocates, resigned. He had written a report giving his views on the issue of transformation.

Smuts says it is clear that concerns over whether the JSC is overlooking white male applicants for positions are being ignored.

Legal advocacy group Freedom Under Law says it’s now considering challenging the way judges are appointed. One of their directors Advocate Jeremy Gauntlett is one of the candidates who has been turned down for a judicial position.

The group alleges that the JSC is too easy on some applicants during interviews, while being unfairly harsh to others.

Legal analysts say it is clear the judiciary is split over the issue of transformation and that a programme is needed to clearly outline the criteria for appointing judges to the judiciary.

 

COLUMN: Journalist Dianne Hawker asks whether the transformation debate should involve us, the public. 

-eNCA

COMMENTS

     

LATEST STORIES

Dutch lead investigators into the shooting down over Ukraine of flight MH17 said Wednesday that data from the cockpit voice recorder was intact and had not been tampered with.
The foreman on the Tongaat Mall building site has blamed the mall’s designer for the partial collapse of the structure.
Five suspects are on the run after shooting two police constables who approached them while patrolling Dawn Park township.

TOP STORIES view all

The bodies of the first victims from a Malaysian airliner shot down over Ukraine last week arrived back in the Netherlands on Wednesday amid dignified grief tinged with anger.
A suicide bomb on Wednesday in the northern Nigeria city of Kaduna killed at least 25 people, police said.
The charges were laid after members of the EFF stormed the Gauteng Legislature on Tuesday and damaged property.

NEWS STREAMcloseview all

This is the overlay

eNCA Subscriptions

Close